Can typing help a child learn to spell? What the handwriting-versus-keyboard studies found

Second graders who practised new words on a keyboard spelled them as well a week later as children who practised with a pencil — if they could already type. Four comparison studies, why they disagree, and what seems to matter more than the tool.

11 min de lectura

Comparte este artículo

Este artículo aún no está traducido a tu idioma, así que se muestra en inglés.

Forty second graders practised spelling ten made-up words. Half of them used a pencil, half used a keyboard. A day later, and again a week later, the two groups recognised and spelled the words equally well3. The same study found the detail that matters for parents: inside the keyboard group, the children who were already good at typing learned more, and the ones who were not learned less.

We make a typing site, so we would like the answer to be that typing teaches spelling. The honest answer is narrower. The studies that compared the two do not agree, the oldest one favoured the pencil, and none of them shows that a keyboard is better. What they do suggest is that the tool matters less than whether the child is actually producing the spelling — and that a keyboard only stops being a handicap once using it is easy.

Three studies, three different answers

The first well-known comparison had 48 first graders practise words in three ways: writing them, arranging letter tiles, and typing them on a computer. Across two experiments, the words practised by hand were spelled best — the paper's title is "Writing beats the computer"1.

A few years later another team taught spelling words to 48 third and fourth graders, half of whom had learning disabilities, by writing, tracing or keyboarding. This time the method made no significant difference to how many words the children learned. The children liked the computer best, but believed they had learned more by writing and tracing — which the results did not bear out2.

The 2014 study at the top of this page then compared printing and typing with made-up words, so that no child could already know them, and tested both recognition and spelling one and seven days later. Again there was no difference between the groups3.

No study here found the keyboard better for spelling. One found the pencil better; two found no difference.

The catch: typing has to be easy first

The most useful result is the one inside the 2014 study. How well a child could already type predicted how much they learned when practising on the keyboard, while how well a child could already print made no such difference when practising with a pencil3. A plausible reading is that a child who is still hunting for each key spends their attention on the keyboard instead of on the word. The study shows the pattern, not the reason.

Learning the letters themselves is a different question, and there the evidence leans one way. When children aged 3 to 5 practised copying letters for three weeks, the older ones recognised letters better after handwriting practice than after typing practice4. So for a child still learning what the letters look like, a keyboard is not a replacement for a pencil.

What seems to matter more than the tool

Across this research, the comparison that keeps producing a difference is not pencil against keyboard but spelling against reading. Third graders who met new words by spelling them learned how the words were written better than when they met them by reading, and the learning showed most clearly when they later had to write the spelling, not just pick it out5.

That is also why copying is a weak form of practice. Ouellette and Tims point out that in an earlier version of the study that found no difference, the children copied the words rather than spelling them from memory3. Copying letter by letter, whether by hand or on a keyboard, can be done without holding the word in mind at all.

Saying words aloud may also help, with a condition attached. In memory experiments, words a person said aloud while studying were remembered better than words read silently — but only when some words were said aloud and others were not. Saying every word aloud did not produce the advantage6. Those were recognition-memory experiments, not studies of children learning to spell, so treat this as a hint rather than a rule.

What the research cannot tell you

  • These are small studies — 40 to 48 children each — with short practice periods. None of them followed the children over months.
  • Three of the studies were about English spelling and one was in Hebrew. Whether the results hold for children learning English as a foreign language, these studies cannot say.
  • The keyboards, software and children's typing experience in 1990 were very different from today's.
  • None of them tested a typing site, including this one. Our lessons show the sentence on screen, which makes typing them closer to copying than to spelling from memory.

What to do at home

  • Keep handwriting for learning the letters. The keyboard evidence does not replace it, and for young children it points the other way.
  • Build typing skill on its own, with short sessions, before expecting the keyboard to help with spelling. A child who has to search for every key is learning the keyboard, not the word.
  • To practise spelling, have the child produce the word without looking: read it, hide it, then write or type it, then check. Either tool works for this step.
  • Pick out the few words that keep going wrong and have the child say just those aloud while practising, rather than every word.

On this site, the word lessons read each word aloud when it is finished and show which finger to use for the next key. That makes them practice in typing and in hearing the word — not, on their own, practice in spelling from memory.

Open the word lessons →

Related: why handing a child a keyboard can make their writing worse →

Referencias

Todas las fuentes son artículos revisados por pares, con enlace. Nada se cita de segunda mano.

  1. 1.

    Cunningham, A. E., & Stanovich, K. E. (1990). Early spelling acquisition: Writing beats the computer. Journal of Educational Psychology, 82(1), 159–162.

    Forty-eight first graders practised spelling words by writing them, by arranging letter tiles, or by typing them on a computer keyboard; across two experiments, words practised by handwriting were spelled best.

    https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0663.82.1.159
  2. 2.

    Vaughn, S., Schumm, J. S., & Gordon, J. (1993). Which motoric condition is most effective for teaching spelling to students with and without learning disabilities?. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 26(3), 191–198.

    Forty-eight third and fourth graders, half of them with learning disabilities, learned spelling words by writing, tracing or keyboarding. The condition made no significant difference to how many words they learned. The children preferred the computer but believed they learned best by writing and tracing.

    https://doi.org/10.1177/002221949302600306
  3. 3.

    Ouellette, G., & Tims, T. (2014). The write way to spell: printing vs. typing effects on orthographic learning. Frontiers in Psychology, 5, 117.

    Forty second graders practised spelling ten made-up words either by printing or on a keyboard. One and seven days later both groups recognised and spelled the words equally well. Within the typing group, children who already typed well learned more; how well children printed made no such difference in the printing group.

    https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2014.00117
  4. 4.

    Longcamp, M., Zerbato-Poudou, M.-T., & Velay, J.-L. (2005). The influence of writing practice on letter recognition in preschool children: A comparison between handwriting and typing. Acta Psychologica, 119(1), 67–79.

    Children aged 3–5 learned to copy letters of the alphabet for three weeks, either by hand or by typing. In the older children, handwriting practice led to better letter recognition than typing practice.

    https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actpsy.2004.10.019
  5. 5.

    Shahar-Yames, D., & Share, D. L. (2008). Spelling as a self-teaching mechanism in orthographic learning. Journal of Research in Reading, 31(1), 22–39.

    Third graders reading Hebrew met new letter strings either by spelling them or by reading them. Spelling produced better learning of how the words were written than reading did, and the learning showed more strongly when the children later had to write the spelling than when they only had to recognise it.

    https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9817.2007.00359.x
  6. 6.

    MacLeod, C. M., Gopie, N., Hourihan, K. L., Neary, K. R., & Ozubko, J. D. (2010). The production effect: Delineation of a phenomenon. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 36(3), 671–685.

    In eight recognition-memory experiments, words said aloud during study were remembered better than words read silently — but only when some words in the same list were said aloud and others were not. Saying every word aloud did not produce the advantage.

    https://doi.org/10.1037/a0018785

Comparte este artículo

Todos los artículos